1931-32 Season (1st)
Dec 1931: The Circle
Feb 1932: The Ship
Apr 1932: The Truth About Blayds

1932-1933 Season (2nd)
Dec 1932: Hellbent for Heaven
Feb 1933: Icebound
Apr 1933: The First Mrs. Fraser
Apr 1933: The Wizard of Oz (children’s show)

1933-1934 Season (3rd)
Oct 1933: Pinocchio (children’s show)
Dec 1933: The Swan
Feb 1934 : Another Language
Apr 1934: Fashion (or: Life in New York) (1st time)

1934-1935 Season (4th)
Oct 1934: Simpleton Simon (children’s show)
Dec 1934: The Perfect Alibi
Jan 1935: Three Workshop Plays: What Never Dies, Half an Hour, The Great Catherine
Feb 1935: Thunder in the Air
Apr 1935: Brief Moment

1935-1936 Season (5th)
Oct 1935: The Tin Soldier (children’s show)
Jan 1936: Her Master’s Voice
Jan 1936: Double Door
Feb 1936: A Doll’s House
Apr 1936: Dulcy

1936-1937 Season (6th)
Oct 1936: The Bluebird (children’s show)
Nov 1936: Post Road
Jan 1937: Children of the Moon
Mar 1937: The Front Page
Apr 1937: The Constant Wife

1938-1938 Season (7th)
Oct 1937: The Emperor’s New Clothes (children’s show)
Nov 1937: The Late Christopher Bean
Dec 1937: The Importance of Being Earnest (1st time)
Feb 1938: Liliom
Apr 1938: Let Us Be Gay

1938-1939 Season (8th)
Nov 1938: The Far Off Hills
Jan 1939: Tonight at 8:30 (1st time)
Mar 1939: The Silver Cord
May 1939: George and Margaret

​1939-1940 Season (9th)
Nov 1939: Kind Lady
Dec 1939: Expressing Willie
Jan 1940: Our Town (1st time)
Mar 1940: Mrs. Moonlight
Apr 1940: The Torchbearers (1st time)

1940-1941 Season (10th)
Nov 1940: Personal Appearance
Jan 1941: The Tavern
Feb 1941: You Can’t Take It With You (1st time)
Apr 1941: Stage Door

1941-1942 Season (11th)
Nov 1941: Flight to the West
Jan 1942: The Bishop Misbehaves
Feb 1942: The Play’s the Thing (1st time)
Apr 1942: George Washington Slept Here

1942-1943 Season (12th)
Nov 1942: The Eve of St. Mark
Jan 1943: Ladies in Retirement
Mar 1943: Fashion (2nd time)
Apr 1943: Private Lives (1st time)

1943-1944 Season (13th)
Nov 1943: Old Acquaintance
Jan 1944: Rebecca
Mar 1944: Out of the Frying Pan
Apr 1944: Arsenic and Old Lace (1st time)

1944-1945 Season (14th)
Nov 1944: Junior Miss
Jan 1945: Biography
Mar 1945: Tovarich
May 1945: Guest in the House

1945-1946 Season (15th)
Nov 1945: The Hasty Heart
Jan 1946: The Little Foxes (1st time)
Mar 1946: First Lady
Apr 1946: The Male Animal (1st time)

1946-1947 Season (16th)
Oct 1946: Yes, My Darling Daughter
Dec 1946: The Visitor
Feb 1947: Mornings at Seven (1st time)
Apr 1947: The Barretts of Wimpole Street

1947-1948 Season (17th)
Nov 1947: Payment Deferred
Jan 1948: Both Your Houses
Mar 1948: Candida
May 1948: Too Many Husbands

1948-1949 Season (18th)
Nov 1948: What Every Woman Knows
Feb 1949: The Magnificent Yankee
Apr 1949: The Two Mrs. Carrolls
May 1949: Friends and Relations

1949-1950 Season (19th)
Oct 1949: Another Part of the Forest
Dec 1949: Command Decision (2nd time)
Jan 1950: Years Ago
Apr 1950: The Heiress

1950-1951 Season (20th)
Oct 1950: Goodbye, My Fancy
Jan 1951: Light Up the Sky
Mar 1951: Edward, My Son
Apr 1951: The Silver Whistle

1961-1962 Season (31st)
Feb 1962: Separate Tables
Mar 1962: Little Red Riding Hood
Apr 1962: See How They Run (1st time)

1962-1963 Season (32nd)
Nov 1962: The Male Animal (2nd time)
Feb 1963: Country Girl
May 1963: The Drunkard (1st time)

1963-1964 Season (33rd)
Nov 1963: Write Me a Murder
Feb 1964: Send Me No Flowers
Apr 1964: Petticoat Fever

​1964-1965 Season (34th)
Nov 1964: Under Milk Wood (1st time)
Feb 1965: Sunday in New York
May 1965: Two One-Act Plays: The Public Eye and The Private Ear

Lafayette Little Theatre Suspended Operations May 15, 1965. The 1966-1967 Season was produced as Civic Theatre of Greater Lafayette.

1966-1967 Season (35th)
Mar 1966: Riverwind
Nov 1966: Spotlight 150
Apr 1967: Mary, Mary

1967-1968 (36th)
Nov 1967: Any Wednesday
May 1968: Never Too Late (1st time)

1968-1969 Season (37th)
Nov 1968: The Odd Couple
May 1969: Come Blow Your Horn

​1969-1970 Season (38th)
Oct 1969: Barefoot in the Park (1st time)
Feb 1970: The Imaginary Invalid (1st time)
May 1970: Cactus Flower

1970-1971 Season (39th)
Nov 1970: Harvey
Feb 1971: The Mousetrap (1st time)
May 1971: Mr. Roberts

1971-1972 Season (40th)
Oct 1971: The Fantasticks
Feb 1972: Two One-Act Plays: The Bald Soprano and Picnic on the Battlefield
Apr 1972: Plaza Suite (1st time)

1972-73 Season (41st)
Oct 1972: The Vinegar Tree
Oct 1972: The Mikado (LaMask)
Feb 1973: The Secretary Bird
Apr 1973: Bell, Book and Candle
Jul 1973: See How They Run (2nd time)

1973-1974 Season (42nd)
Sep 1973: I Never Sang for My Father
Oct 1973: H.M.S. Pinafore (LaMask)
Feb 1974: A Thousand Clowns (1st time)
Apr 1974: How the Other Half Loves
Jul 1974: Sailor Beware

1974-1975 Season (43rd)
Nov 1974: Naughty Marietta (LaMask)
Oct 1974: The Drunkard (2nd time)
Feb 1975: You Know I Can’t Hear You When the Water’s Running
Apr 1975: I am a Camera
Jul 1975: The Prisoner of Second Avenue

1975-1976 Season (44th)
Oct 1975: Showboat
Nov 1975: The Lark
Feb 1976: Tonight with Noel Coward
Apr 1976: What the Butler Saw
Jul 1976: Four on a Garden

1976-1977 Season (45th)
Oct 1976: Oklahoma!
Dec 1976: The Good Doctor
Feb 1977: 6 Rms Riv Vu
Apr 1977: Night Watch
Jul 1977: Wine, Women and Song

1977-1978 Season (46th)
Sep 1977: Arsenic and Old Lace (2nd time)
Nov 1977: Under Milk Wood (2nd time)
Feb 1978: The Play’s the Thing (3rd time)
Apr 1978: Man of La Mancha
Jul 1978: Starting Here, Starting Now

1978-1979 Season (47th)
Oct 1978: The Lady from Maxim’s
Nov 1978: The Night of January 16th
Feb 1979: Never Too Late (2nd time)
Apr 1979: Little Mary Sunshine
Jul 1979: Side by Side by Sondheim

1979-1980 Season (48th)
Oct 1979: California Suite
Nov 1979: Tea and Sympathy
Feb 1980: Becket
Apr 1980: Fiddler on the Roof (1st time)
Jul 1980: Bullshot Crummond

1980-1981 Season (49th)
Oct 1980: The Women
Nov 1980: The Little Foxes (2nd time)
Feb 1981: Tonight at 8:30 (2nd time)
Apr 1981: Camelot

1981-1982 Season (50th Season)
Oct 1981: I Do, I Do (1st time)
Nov 1981: Inherit the Wind
Feb 1982: Dial “M” for Murder (2nd time)
Apr 1982: Guys and Dolls (200th Production)
Jun 1982: The Very Great Grandson of Sherlock Holmes

1992-1993 Season (61st)
Sep 1992: Little Shop of Horrors (1st time)
Oct 1992: Strange Loves
Nov 1992: Who’s Afraid of Virginia Wolf
Dec 1992: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (1st time)
Feb 1993: Lend Me a Tenor (1st time)
Mar 1993: Road to Nirvana
Apr 1993: A Few Good Men
May 1993: Marvin’s Room (1st time)
Jun 1993: Same Time Next Year

1993-1994 Season (62nd)
Sep 1993: Into the Woods (1st time)
Oct 1993: The Big Funk
Nov 1993: The Petrified Forest
Dec 1993: A Child’s Christmas in Wales
Feb 1994: The Imaginary Invalid (2nd time)
Mar 1994: Sweet Sue
Apr 1994: The Voice of the Prairie
Jun 1994: Prelude to a Kiss

1994-1995 Season (63rd)
Sep 1994: Meet Me in St. Louis
Oct 1994: Shadow Box
Nov 1994: The Cemetery Club
Feb 1995: The Grapes of Wrath
Mar 1995: Beyond Therapy
Apr 1995: I Hate Hamlet
Jun 1995: Baby

1995-1996 Season (64th)
Sep 1995: Brigadoon
Oct 1995: Talk Radio
Nov 1995: The Sunshine Boys
Feb 1996: To Kill a Mockingbird (1st time)
Mar 1996: All in the Timing
Apr 1996: Arsenic and Old Lace (3rd time)
Jun 1996: Nunsense II
Jul 1996: Annie Get Your Gun
Aug 1996: Some Enchanted Evening (1st time)

1996-1997 Season (65th)
Sep 1996: Forever Plaid (1st time)
Oct 1996: Sylvia (1st time)
Nov 1996: The Female Odd Couple
Feb 1997: The Miracle Worker
Mar 1997: Orphans
Apr 1997: Wait Until Dark
Jun 1997: They’re Playing Our Song
Jul 1997: Smoke on the Mountain
Jul 1997: Tom Sawyer (300th Production)
Aug 1997: South Pacific (1st time)

1997-1998 Season (66th)
Sep 1997: Gypsy
Oct 1997: Eleemosynary
Nov 1997: The Boys Next Door (1st time)
Feb 1998: A Streetcar Named Desire
Mar 1998: Death and the Maiden
Apr 1998: Rumors
Jun 1998: I Do, I Do (2nd time)
Jul 1998: Oklahoma! (2nd time)
Jul 1998: Alice in Wonderland
Aug 1998: You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown

1998-1999 Season (67th)
Sep 1998: You Can’t Take it with You (3rd time)
Oct 1998: Flesh and Blood
Nov 1998: The Trip to Bountiful
Dec 1998: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2nd time)
Feb 1999: Pump Boys and Dinettes (2nd time)
Mar 1999: The Old Boy
Apr 1999: Sisters Rosenweig
Jun 1999: Daddy’s Dy’in (Who’s Got the Will?)

1999-2000 Season (68th)
Jul 1999: Grease (1st time)
Jul 1999: Winnie the Pooh
Aug 1999: 1940’s Radio Hour
Sep 1999; Greater Tuna (1st time)
Oct 1999: John Lennon and Me
Nov 1999: Elephant Man
Feb 2000: The World Goes Round
Apr 2000: The Bad Seed
Apr 2000: The Old Boy
Jun 2000: Moon Over Buffalo

2000-2001 Season (69th)
Jul 2000: 1776
Jul 2000: Bye Bye Birdie
Aug 2000: Snow White & the Seven Dwarfs
Sep 2000: Proposals
Nov 2000: A Tuna Christmas
Feb 2001: The Eighth Order
Mar 2001: Kiss Me Kate
Apr 2001: The Glass Menagerie (3rd time)
May 2001: Barefoot in the Park

2001-2002 Season (70th)
Jul 2001: State Fair
Jul 2001: Henry & Ramona
Aug 2001: Always…Patsy Cline
Sep 2001: Last Night of Ballyhoo
Nov 2001: Always…Patsy Cline
Feb 2002: Marvin’s Room (2nd time)
Mar 2002: Fiddler on the Roof (2nd time)
May 2002: Plaza Suite (2nd time)

2002-2003 Season (71st)
Jul 2002: Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Aug 2002: GI Juke Box
Sep 2002: Over the River and Through the Woods
Nov 2002: Frank-ly Speaking
Jan 2003: Of Mice and Men
Mar 2003: Annie (1st time)
May 2003: Don’t Dress for Dinner

2003-2004 Season (72nd)
Jul 2003: The Music Man
Aug 2003: Charlotte’s Web
Sep 2003: Amadeus
Nov 2003: Quilters
Feb 2004: A Chorus Line (2nd time)
Mar 2004: Picasso at the Lapin Agile
May 2004: Cheaper by the Dozen

2004-2005 Season (73rd)
Jul 2004: Carousel
Aug 2004: Wind in the Willows
Sep 2004: Crimes of the Heart
Nov 2004: My Fair Lady
Feb 2005: Squabbles
Apr 2005: One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
May 2005: Honk!

2004-2005 Season (74th)
Jul 2005: The Sound of Music (2nd time)
Jul 2005: The Hobbit
Sep 2005: The Mind with the Dirty Man
Nov 2005: Suds
Jan 2006: The Diary of Anne Frank
Mar 2006: The Nerd
May 2006: I Love You You’re Perfect Now Change

2006-2007 Season (75th)
Jul 2006: Grease (2nd time)
Jul 2006: Some Enchanted Evening (2nd time)
Sep 2006: Forever Plaid (2nd time)
Nov 2006: Lend Me a Tenor (2nd time)
Jan 2007: On Golden Pond (2nd time)
Mar 2007: Nunsense (2nd time)
May 2007: Greater Tuna (2nd time)

2007-2008 Season (76th)
Jul 2007: Jesus Christ Superstar
Jul 2007: The Fantasticks (2nd time)
Sep 2007: Steel Magnolias (2nd time)
Dec 2007: Plaid Tidings
Feb 2008: The Crucible
Apr 2008: Crowns
May 2008: The Odd Couple (2nd time)

2008-2009 Season (77th)
Jul 2008: High School Musical
Sep 2008: Honky Tonk Angels
Nov 2008: Proof
Jan 2009: The Man Who Came to Dinner
Mar 2009: Children of Eden
May 2009: Private Lives (2nd time)

2009-2010 Season (78th)
Jul 2009: The King and I (2nd time)
Sep 2009: The Mousetrap
Dec 2009: A Christmas Story
Jan 2010: A Raisin in the Sun
Mar 2010: The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (abridged)
May 2010: Cabaret (400th Production)

2010-2011 Season (79th)
Sep 2010: The Taffetas
Nov 2010: Tuesdays with Morrie
Jan 2011: All My Sons
Mar 2011: Out of Order
May 2011: Little Shop of Horrors (2nd time)

2011-2012 Season (80th)
Jul 2011: Rent
Sep 2011: Come Back to the Five & Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean
Nov 2011: Love Letters
Dec 2011: Honky Tonk Angels Holiday Spectacular
Jan 2012: Rabbit Hole
Mar 2012: Red Hot and Cole (2nd time)
May 2012: Tartuffe
Jun 2012: Red, White and Tuna

2012-2013 Season (81st)
Sep 2012: My Way
Oct 2012: Woman in Black
Nov 2012: Nuncrackers
Jan 2013: Arcadia
Mar 2013: The Fox on the Fairway
May 2013: Company

2013-2014 Season (82nd)
Sep 2013: Still Kicking
Oct 2013: Witness for the Prosecution
Dec 2013: It’s a Wonderful Life, a Radio Play
Jan 2014: Bus Stop (2nd time)
Mar 2014: Lost in Yonkers
May 2014: Mame